I supported the 2014 Umbrella Movement. I didn't like the corruption and
authoritarianism in Mainland China. And I don't like quite a few of the
legislators in the pro-Establishment camp, and certain high-ranking
(ex-)officers of the government of Hong Kong.
There, I said it.
I was there at Admiralty when OCLP happened. I was largely supportive of what
the students were doing there - i.e. just occupying the area around the Central
Government Offices, and protesting directly at the government - until things
started to spread, turn violent, and go out of control.
With that being said, I also don't like quite a few of the legislators in the
"pan-democracy" camp.
I can sympathise with their demand to withdraw ELAB, but I definitely do not
agree with their methods.
So, dear reader, I hope you don't label me as either a "Blue Ribbon" or a
"Yellow Ribbon" and dismiss me outright.
Why Am I Writing This?
Because I think what's happening is wrong. Because riots is not how I think
Democracy works. Because I feel that those who oppose the riots are under-
represented on Western social media, such as Twitter and Reddit. Because Hong
Kong is my birth place.
What I Saw Is Not What You Saw.
A lot of you have probably seen montages, posters, or short clips about how the
Hong Kong police are abusing their power, terrorising people, being trigger-
happy, firing tear gas indiscriminately, and brutalising protesters.
But that's not the whole picture, not even close.
Here's the thing: a lot of those montages or short clips are cherry-picked by
rioters, or by foreign propaganda makers; some of the stuff is
even completely fabricated FUD.
And then compassionate, but misguided, supporters of the rioters spread those
half-truths and utter falsehoods further and faster in the online world.
In reality, the rioters have done horrible things and caused massive
damage and destruction to innocent citizens and to Hong Kong society as a
whole. Those facts are conveniently omitted from the pro-rioter propaganda.
I'm going to fill you in on just some of their wrong-doings that I can recall.
Note that some of the things I list below have been perpetrated repeatedly
and regularly by rioters over the past few months. In all cases, I only link
to a single report as reference. You can easily search for more examples by
using the relevant keywords in your favourite web search engine.
Protesters illegally detained and abused a journalist of the Global Times
during a sit-in of the Hong Kong International Airport [1].
Rioters vandalised and destroyed public road and highway facilities. They dug
up bricks as weapons [2], dismantled metal railing to make roadblocks
[5], destroyed traffic lights [3], and
graffitied everywhere [4]. All of these costed tax payer money to
build and will cost even more to repair.
Rioters assaulted civilians who attempted to film them; the most famous
victim being actress Celine Ma [7].
Rioters assaulted civilians who disagree with them or who they suspect are
(undercover) police, often with other rioters making a curtain of umbrellas
so that nobody can film who the perpetrators of violence are [6].
Rioters doxxed policemen and made death threats to their families [8].
Rioters harassed the reporting crew of TVB, destroyed their filming
equipment, and confiscated their SD card, on separate occasions, all
illegally [9]; because they don't like TVB reporting on their other
violent and illegal acts.
Rioters doused a man in gasoline and set him on fire because the man
disagreed with them [10].
Rioters set fire to toll booths of a cross-harbour tunnel [11].
Rioters vandalised restaurants owned or operated under franchise by Maxim's
Caterers Limited because the founder's daughter voiced her opposition to the
riots [12]. They also vandalised other Chinese-funded banks and shops.
E.g. they broke in, trashed the places, destroyed CCTV and ATM machines, and
set fire to the places [13].
Rioters set fire to street-level shops, with complete disregard that there
are people living in the floors above [15].
Rioters put trash (including rocks, rods, and a bicycle) on railroads of the
MTR, disregarding that fact that it may derail trains, and cause serious
injury, even death, to passengers [16].
Rioters threw a Molotov cocktail at a running MTR train, disregarding the
life of the passengers inside [17].
Rioters dropped objects from a bridge onto a busy highway below, disregarding
the safety of motorists [18].
Rioters threw objects from high ground, at moving cars and at people who
tried to clean up the roadblocks set by the rioters. One man was hit on the
head by a brick, another barely avoided a chair [19].
Rioters assaulted civilians who tried to clean up the roadblocks set by the
rioters [20].
Rioters vandalised train stations, setting fire [22], destroying facilities such
as toll gates, ticketing machines, and platform displays [21].
Rioters vandalised major shopping malls. They broke the tempered glass that
support the guardrails, and set fire to a giant Christmas Tree at Festival
Walk, disregarding the hazard it could cause - the fire would release a huge
amount of toxic gas and the tree could tumble over due to fire damage and
seriously injure people, including the security guards, and mall staff who
watch helplessly, and the rioters themselves [23].
Rioters occupied university campuses, stole hazardous lab materials [24], and made
stockpiles of Molotov cocktail inside [25].
Rioters ambushed and assaulted off-duty policemen [26].
Rioters shot a police media liaison officer with an arrow [27].
Rioters in school campuses are now chanting "revenge" as slogan. They have
stopped pretending to be fighting for a greater cause.
Rioters threw Molokov cocktails around a school bus with children inside
[28].
Rioters utterly trashed the PolyU campus during their barricade
[30].
The city-wide destruction is causing massive cripplings or even shutdowns of
the public transport system [31]; suspension of
kindergarten, primary school, and high schools [32]; chaos,
massive delays, and even endangerment to commuters [33]. The rioters
are depriving children of their right to safely go to school, to libraries, and
to playgrounds. They are depriving patients of their right to timely treatment,
of citizens' right to timely fire rescue [34]. They are dragging with
them, on purpose, everybody who wants nothing to do with the protests.
"Protesters"
By now, I hope you realise that the labelling of "protesters" by the Western
media is a misnomer, especially in the later months of the clashes. They are
not courageous, unarmed, peaceful, underdog protesters. They are armed with
bricks paid for by tax payers; metal pipes; Molotov cocktails. They are
violent. They are organised and coordinated, using Telegram/Signal/other mesh
messaging apps. They are rioters terrorising citizens of Hong Kong using
cowardly tactics. Period.
"Pro-Democracy"
What they are doing is also not pro-democracy. This is not democracy. This not
even how you fight for democracy, not by a long shot.
Democracy is not trying to bash somebody else's skull in, setting them on fire,
or making death threats to their families because they disagree with you.
Democracy is not trying to force everybody to cooperate with you in your
fight. Democracy is not trying to take the whole society hostage, regardless of
how great and just you believe your cause to be [14].
Democracy is based on the premise that people are civilised, that people who
hold different opinions can be reasoned with. Otherwise, why do we hold
debates in the LegCo [35]?
If you don't believe in even that premise, then you cannot claim that you
believe in Democracy. You can say you are fighing for something, just that
something is simply not Democracy. You may be anti-government, but you are
not pro-Democracy.
When you disagree with something, you can try to vote the opposing party out,
you can protest, you can organise assembly and march to show your numbers. But
if you find yourself outnumbered by people of opposite or diverging opinion,
then that's JUST TOO BAD. You don't throw a fit, especially not one that
involves physical violence on a massive scale. Instead, you try harder to
reach out, reason with, and convince more people to agree and side with you.
You may fail, and you shall keep trying; because only then are you fighting the
good fight.
As it stands, I don't see the protesters reaching out and trying harder to
convince fellow citizens. For all the money and effort they have spent on
buying gas masks, making Molotov cocktails and other makeshift weapons, and
coordinating other riot activities, they could have tried to come up with
better, more compelling arguments for Hong Kong people to stand against ELAB.
Instead, they took the easy [36] route of rioting.
I'm not saying that "Blue Ribbons" have not been ass holes. Some of them have
also harassed, verbally abused, and physically assaulted supporters or
participants of the Umbrella Movement in the past. But you are not them. You
can and should do better.
The rioters may believe that most Hong Kongers are opposed to the ELAB. And I
can give them the benefit of the doubt. After all, over a million Hong Kong
people have initially marched against the bill. That's a number that most
people, including pro-establishment folks, can agree on. But in practical
terms, the people of Hong Kong had cast their votes. They would rather go to
work, go to school, or go shopping than to spend more effort opposing ELAB.
Most especially do not want to engage in acts of indiscriminate violence in the
name of a greater cause. In other words, there are maybe lots of people
kinda sorta opposed to ELAB, but not opposed enough to do much about it.
Because children still need to be fed; kids still need to go to school; people
still need to make a living. Because life is not perfect, life is not all
binary. And you have no right to drag them with you.
"Police Brutality"
I'm going out of my way to defend the police here. Yes, the police fired tear gas, rubber bullets, and even live
rounds. You may have seen montages of police allegedly using excessive force. But those are short clips or even single
frames out of longer footages of confrontation, cherry-picked by rioters or their supporters. The police is under the
constant scrutiny of multiple news media filming crews. The police are held accountable; you only have to look at the
beating of Ken Tsang to see that this is the case. During this year's riots, the police give ample warning to
rioters (blue, orange, red, then black banners); every live shot was fired in defense. Some people point out that the
live shots were fired at point blank, but they are missing the point. The rioters were ganging up on police officers.
The police officers gave ample verbal warning to the rioters to not approach. You could even see one of the rioters
trying to steal the policeman's gun. There was no time for police officers to distant themselves. So they shot at
point blank.
You can also look at it from a numerical point of view. Since March 2019, there has not been a single death caused
by police action. Instead, rioters threw bricks and hit a 70-year-old outsource worker of the Food and Environmental
Hygiene Department, resulting in his death, all because he was trying to film the conflict between rioters and local
residents, a conflict to which he took no part.
Where Are the People Opposed to the Riots?
I don't know if you have ever asked yourself this question, but this is a good time to be asking it because I'm about to
give you an answer. I don't have supporting numbers; the answer is not definitive, but (I believe) still very plausible
one.
If you just focus on Twitter and Reddit, the answer is that they are simply not really on Twitter and Reddit. Most of
the people who are opposed to the riots just happen to not be on Twitter and Reddit. Instead, they are in "Blue Ribbon"
Facebook groups, on WeChat, on Weibo. A lot of them also write in Chinese instead of English. If you, as a foreigner,
can't read Chinese, there is no way you can understand what the local people are actually thinking and saying.
The modern "social networks" also create these bubbles that really don't encourage meaningful political discourse. We're
all being herded into separate groups by algorithms. Staying in these groups means amplifying your confirmation bias.
When OCLP happened in 2014, the students staged a lengthy sit-in
around the Central Government Officed and blocked Harcourt Road because,
after all, there were really that many students showing their numbers. For a
very long time they did not turn violent, they did not try to drag the whole
of Hong Kong with them on purpose. People could still go to work, go to
school, etc. They didn't block access roads to hospitals. And I was ok with
that.
"Easy" in the intellectual sense. When you riot, you let yourself be
driven by emotions; and you assume your peers are also driven by emotions.
You give up on on reasoning. But then it becomes a game of "Who Shouts the
Loudest?".
Comments
comments powered by Disqus